| Cover | | Date
 | Title  Album | Points
 | US peak | UK peak | US AC peak | US country peak | US dance peak | US R&B peak | Comment |
|---|
| Aileen Stanley |
| 1. | 07/1921 | | 56
 | 11 US | | | | | | [Vocalion 14172] written by Milton Ager, Benny Davis & Lester Santly |
| Marion Harris |
| 2. | 10/1921 | | 129
 | 3 US | | | | | | [Columbia 3433] written by Milton Ager, Benny Davis & Lester Santly |
| Paul Whiteman & His Orchestra |
| 3. | 06/1923 | | 125
 | 4 US | | | | | | [Victor 19030] written by Harry Akst & Benny Davis  |
| Nora Bayes |
| 4. | 06/1923 | | 103
 | 7 US | | | | | | [Columbia 3862] written by Harry Akst & Benny Davis  |
| Lewis James |
| 5. | 08/1925 | | 103
 | 7 US | | | | | | [Victor 19623] written by Benny Davis , Joe Burke & Mark Fisher |
| Irving Kaufman |
| 6. | 09/1925 | | 58
 | 11 US | | | | | | [Vocalion 15023] written by Benny Davis , Joe Burke & Mark Fisher |
| The Benson Orchestra of Chicago |
| 7. | 10/1925 | | 110
 | 6 US | | | | | | [Victor 19685] written by Benny Davis , Joe Burke & Mark Fisher |
| The Ipana Troubadors |
| 8. | 11/1926 | | 86
 | 10 US | | | | | | [Columbia 696] written by Harry Akst & Benny Davis  |
| Whispering Jack Smith |
| 9. | 12/1926 | | 108
 | 6 US | | | | | | [Victor 20229] written by Harry Akst & Benny Davis  |
| Judy Garland |
| 10. | 08/1940 | | 133
 | 3 US | | | | | | [songwriter #4 hit] hit for Marion Harris in 1921 [Decca 3174] written by Milton Ager, Benny Davis & Lester Santly |
|
| Bea Wain |
| 11. | 08/1940 | | 49
 | 15 US | | | | | | [Victor 26603] written by Milton Ager, Benny Davis & Lester Santly |
| Ozzie Nelson and His Orchestra |
| 12. | 08/1940 | | 45
 | 16 US | | | | | | vocals by Rose Ann Stevens written by Milton Ager, Benny Davis & Lester Santly |
| Sarah Vaughan |
| 13. | 10/1949 | | 51
 | 20 US | | | | | | [Columbia 38559] written by Jack Shilkret & Benny Davis  |
| Perry Como |
| 14. | 09/1950 | | 130
 | 7 US | | | | | | [songwriter #5 hit] [RCA 47-3905] written by Benny Davis  |
| Sunny Gale |
| 15. | 09/1952 | | 61
 | 14 US | | | | | | [RCA 47-4789] written by Abner Silver & Benny Davis  |
| Eddie Fisher |
| 16. | 07/1953 | | 119
 | 7 US | | | | | | [RCA 47-5365] written by Benny Davis & Abner Silver |
| Frankie Laine |
| 17. | 10/1954 | | 67
 | | 9 UK | | | | | [Columbia 40235] written by Benny Davis & Ted Murry |
| Little Richard |
| 18. | 09/1958 | | 141
 | 41 US | 2 UK | | | | 12 R&B | [songwriter #3 hit] [Specialty 645] written by Harry Akst & Benny Davis  |
| Joni James |
| 19. | 09/1958 | | 47
 | 19 US | | | | | | [MGM 12706] written by Benny Davis & Abner Silver |
| Fats Domino |
| 20. | 05/1959 | | 54
 | 51 US | 18 UK | | | | | B side to I'm Ready [Imperial 5585] written by Benny Davis , Con Conrad & Russel Robinson |
| Shirley Bassey |
| 21. | 04/1960 | | 16
 | | 38 UK | | | | | written by Abner Silver & Benny Davis  |
| Jeanne Black |
| 22. | 12/1960 | | 9
 | 63 US | | | | | | [Capitol 4492] written by Benny Davis , Joe Burke & Mark Fisher |
| Bobby Vee |
| 23. | 05/1961 | | 2
 | 119 US | | | | | | [Liberty 55325] written by Benny Davis & Harry Akst |
| Connie Francis |
| 24. | 12/1961 | | 64
 | 26 US | 30 UK | 7 AC | | | | [Christmas] US B side to When the Boy in Your Arms (Is the Boy in Your Heart) [MGM 13051] written by Benny Davis & Ted Murry |
| 25. | 02/1962 | | 219
 | ✫1 US | 39 UK | ✫1 AC | | | | [songwriter #1 hit] [MGM 13059] written by Benny Davis & Ted Murry |
| Bobby Darin |
| 26. | 09/1962 | | 30
 | 42 US | 40 UK | | | | | [Atco 6236] written by Benny Davis & Harry Akst |
| Connie Francis |
| 27. | 12/1962 | | 2
 | 113 US | | | | | | [R] [Christmas] written by Benny Davis & Ted Murry |
| 28. | 03/1963 | | 63
 | 17 US | | 7 AC | | | | [MGM 13127] written by Benny Davis & Ted Murry |
| Larry Cunningham & the Mighty Avons |
| 29. | 12/1964 | | 15
 | | 40 UK | | | | | written by Joe Allison, Audrey Allison, Harlan Howard, Benny Davis , Joe Burke, Mark Fisher, Ralph Freed, Jerry Livingston & Eddie Masterson |
| Connie Francis |
| 30. | 01/1965 | | 24
 | 43 US | | 7 AC | | | | written by Benny Davis & Ted Murry |
| Tom Jones |
| 31. | 07/1965 | | 97
 | 27 US | 13 UK | 3 AC | | | | hit for Eddie Fisher in 1953 [Parrot 9787] written by Abner Silver & Benny Davis  |
| The Wing and a Prayer Fife & Drum Corps |
| 32. | 11/1975 | | 152
 | 14 US | 12 UK | 6 AC | | 2 dance | 32 R&B | [songwriter #2 hit] [Wing and a Prayer 103] written by Harry Akst & Benny Davis  |
| Margo Smith |
| 33. | 03/1978 | | 28
 | 104 US | | 40 AC | ✫1 country | | | [Warner 8506] written by Benny Davis & Ted Murry |
| Jim Reeves & Deborah Allen |
| 34. | 11/1979 | | 13
 | | | | 6 country | | | written by Benny Davis , Joe Burke & Mark Fisher |
| Top 100 hits | 27 | 10 | 7 | 2 | 1 | 2 | |
| Top 40 hits | 22 | 10 | 7 | 2 | 1 | 2 | |
| Top 10 hits | 11 | 2 | 6 | 2 | 1 | | |
| ✫ #1 hits | 1 | | 1 | 1 | | | |
| US | UK | AC | country | dance | R&B | |