| Cover | | Date
 | Title  Album | Points
 | US peak | UK peak | US AC peak | US R&B peak | Comment |
|---|
| 1. | 02/1956 | | 335
 | 6 US | ✫1 UK | | ✫1 R&B | [songwriter #1 hit] as The Teenagers featuring Frankie Lymon
[Rolling Stone 500 Greatest Songs #307] [Gee 1002] written by Frankie Lymon, Herman Santiago & George Goldner  |
| 2. | 02/1956 | | 69
 | 12 US | | | | [songwriter #5 hit] [Mercury 70790] written by Frankie Lymon, Herman Santiago & George Goldner  |
| 3. | 03/1956 | | 116
 | 9 US | | | | [songwriter #3 hit] written by Frankie Lymon, Herman Santiago & George Goldner  |
|
| 4. | 08/1956 | | 36
 | | 25 UK | | | written by Frankie Lymon, Herman Santiago & George Goldner  |
| 5. | 03/1957 | | 53
 | | 12 UK | | | written by George Goldner  |
| 6. | 01/1958 | | 77
 | 15 US | | | 2 R&B | [songwriter #4 hit]
[Rolling Stone 500 Greatest Songs #195] [End 1005] written by Richard Barrett, Arlene Smith & George Goldner  |
| 7. | 03/1958 | | 27
 | 39 US | | | 16 R&B | [End 1015] written by George Goldner  |
| 8. | 06/1958 | | 20
 | 42 US | | | 14 R&B | [End 1020] written by George Goldner & Sonny Norton |
| 9. | 02/1964 | | 2
 | 120 US | | | | [Capitol 5118] written by Frankie Lymon, Herman Santiago (uncredited), George Goldner (uncredited) & Morris Levy |
| 10. | 12/1964 | | 5
 | 91 US | | | | [Red Bird 10019] written by Richard Barrett, Arlene Smith & George Goldner  |
| 11. | 01/1965 | | 4
 | 98 US | | | | [Roulette 4591] written by Richard Barrett & George Goldner  |
| 12. | 09/1967 | | 14
 | 41 US | | | | [B.t. Puppy 532] written by Frankie Lymon, Herman Santiago (uncredited), George Goldner (uncredited) & Morris Levy |
| 13. | 12/1969 | | 2
 | 116 US | | | | [Roulette 7064] written by Richard Barrett, Arlene Smith & George Goldner  |
| 14. | 04/1970 | | 2
 | 110 US | | | | [Columbia 45128] written by Richard Barrett, Arlene Smith & George Goldner  |
| 15. | 06/1970 | | 46
 | 29 US | | | 4 R&B | [Roulette 7079] written by Richard Barrett, Arlene Smith & George Goldner  |
| 16. | 06/1972 | | 5
 | 102 US | | | 40 R&B | [Astroscope 104] written by Frankie Lymon, Herman Santiago (uncredited), George Goldner (uncredited) & Morris Levy |
| 17. | 02/1973 | | 3
 | 103 US | | | | [Sire 701] written by Frankie Lymon & George Goldner  |
| 18. | 10/1980 | | 3
 | 102 US | | | | [live] [Asylum 47038] written by Frankie Lymon, Herman Santiago (uncredited), George Goldner (uncredited) & Morris Levy |
| 19. | 10/1981 | | 256
 | 7 US | 4 UK | 2 AC | 6 R&B | [songwriter #2 hit] written by Frankie Lymon, Herman Santiago (uncredited), George Goldner (uncredited) & Morris Levy |
| 20. | 10/1989 | | 4
 | | 84 UK | | | [R] written by Frankie Lymon, Herman Santiago (uncredited), George Goldner (uncredited) & Morris Levy |
| Top 100 hits | 11 | 5 | 1 | 7 | |
| Top 40 hits | 7 | 4 | 1 | 7 | |
| Top 10 hits | 3 | 2 | 1 | 4 | |
| ✫ #1 hits | | 1 | | 1 | |
| US | UK | AC | R&B | |