| | Artist | Points
  | Songs |
|---|
| 1. | Prince's Orchestra | 2366 | 01/1916 • Back Home in Tennessee • 214 pts
04/1916 • Hello, Hawaii, How are You? • 345 pts
05/1916 • St. Louis Blues • 235 pts
06/1916 • The Hesitating Blues • 137 pts
06/1916 • Underneath the Stars • 195 pts
06/1916 • So Long, Letty • 213 pts
07/1916 • The Star-Spangled Banner • 343 pts
09/1916 • Babes in the Wood • 214 pts
09/1916 • Missouri Waltz • 235 pts
11/1916 • Joe Turner Blues • 235 pts |
| 2. | John McCormack | 1868 | 01/1916 • Somewhere a Voice Is Calling • 343 pts
04/1916 • Beautiful Isle of Somewhere • 235 pts
05/1916 • The Old Refrain • 296 pts
05/1916 • A Little Bit of Heaven (Shure, They Call it Ireland) • 149 pts
09/1916 • Tales of Hoffman: Barcarolle (Belle Nuit - Oh Night of Love) • 250 pts
11/1916 • Cradle Song 1915 • 250 pts
12/1916 • The Sunshine of Your Smile • 344 pts |
| 3. | Henry Burr & Albert Campbell | 1635 | 02/1916 • Is There Still Room for Me 'Neath the Old Apple Tree? • 296 pts
02/1916 • The Wedding of the Sunshine and the Rose • 235 pts
07/1916 • There's a Quaker Down in Quaker Town • 343 pts
09/1916 • Through These Wonderful Glasses of Mine • 214 pts
11/1916 • She is the Sunshine of Virginia • 251 pts
12/1916 • You Were Just Made to Order for Me • 296 pts |
| 4. | Al Jolson | 1632 | 06/1916 • Yaaka Hula Hickey Dula • 296 pts
07/1916 • Where Did Robinson Crusoe Go with Friday on Saturday Night? • 195 pts
08/1916 • Down Where the Swanne River Flows • 250 pts
09/1916 • I Sent My Wife to the Thousand Isles • 344 pts
09/1916 • You're a Dangerous Girl • 296 pts
12/1916 • I'm Saving Up the Means to Get to New Orleans • 250 pts |
| 5. | The Peerless Quartet | 1623 | 01/1916 • I Think We've Got Another Washington (Wilson is His Name) • 250 pts
02/1916 • When Old Bill Bailey Plays the Ukelele • 177 pts
03/1916 • The Lights of My Home Town • 343 pts
07/1916 • Arrah Go On, I'm Going Back to Oregon • 177 pts
07/1916 • There's a Quaker Down in Quaker Town • 214 pts
09/1916 • The Honolulu Blues • 149 pts
09/1916 • Welcome, Honey, to Your Old Plantation Home • 137 pts
10/1916 • Dear Old Dreamy Honolulu Town • 177 pts |
| 6. | Billy Murray | 1502 | 03/1916 • When I Get Back to the U.S.A. • 149 pts
04/1916 • Hello, Hawaii, How Are You? • 296 pts
04/1916 • I Love a Piano • 343 pts
10/1916 • Pretty Baby • 342 pts
10/1916 • When You Drop Off at Cairo, Illinois • 137 pts
11/1916 • There's a Little Bit of Bad in Every Good Little Girl • 235 pts |
| 7. | Henry Burr | 1374 | 02/1916 • M-O-T-H-E-R (A Word That Means the World to Me) • 346 pts
03/1916 • My Mother's Rosary • 235 pts
04/1916 • What a Wonderful Mother You'd Be • 149 pts
05/1916 • Memories • 149 pts
06/1916 • Good-Bye, Good Luck, God Bless You (Is All That I Can Say) • 346 pts
07/1916 • Baby Shoes • 149 pts |
| 8. | Enrico Caruso | 681 | 06/1916 • O Sole Mio (My Sunshine) • 250 pts
11/1916 • Santa Lucia (Neapolitan Folk Song) • 235 pts
12/1916 • Cantique de Noel (Holy Night) • 195 pts |
| 9. | Alma Gluck | 681 | 06/1916 • My Old Kentucky Home • 250 pts
08/1916 • The Nightingale Song • 235 pts
11/1916 • Sing Me to Sleep • 195 pts |
| 10. | Arthur Collins & Byron Harlan | 669 | 02/1916 • You'd Never Know That Old Home Town of Mine • 149 pts
07/1916 • Yaaka Hula Hickey Dula • 177 pts
10/1916 • Oh How She Could Yacki Hacki Wicki Wachi Woo (That's Love in Honolulu) • 343 pts |
| 11. | Harry Macdonough | 594 | 02/1916 • Araby • 250 pts
04/1916 • The Girl on the Magazine • 344 pts |
| 12. | The Columbia Mixed Double Quartet | 556 | 08/1916 • America • 343 pts
08/1916 • The Battle Hymn of the Republic • 214 pts |
| 13. | Marguerite Farrell | 539 | 09/1916 • If I Knock the 'L' Out of Kelly (It Would Still be Kelly to Me) • 344 pts
11/1916 • By the Sad Luana Shore • 195 pts |
| 14. | Anna Chandler | 536 | 04/1916 • When You're Down in Louisville • 161 pts
05/1916 • Hello, Hawaii, How Are You? • 161 pts
06/1916 • You Can't Get Along with 'Em or without 'Em • 214 pts |
| 15. | Geoffrey O'Hara | 509 | 07/1916 • All I Want is a Cottage, Some Roses, and You • 296 pts
08/1916 • They Made it Twice as Nice as Paradise (And They Called it Dixieland) • 213 pts |
| 16. | Charles Harrison | 493 | 05/1916 • She's the Daughter of Mother Machree • 149 pts
10/1916 • Ireland Must be Heaven, for My Mother Came from There • 344 pts |
| 17. | Olive Kline & Lambert Murphy | 446 | 04/1916 • So Long, Letty • 195 pts
10/1916 • Have a Heart • 250 pts |
| 18. | Nora Bayes | 412 | 08/1916 • Hello, Hawaii, How Are You? • 177 pts
10/1916 • For Dixie and Uncle Sam • 235 pts |
| 19. | The American Quartet | 400 | 01/1916 • Along the Rocky Road to Dublin • 250 pts
06/1916 • Siam • 149 pts |
| 20. | Taylor Trio | 396 | 01/1916 • The Rosary • 161 pts
03/1916 • The Old Folks at Home • 235 pts |
| 21. | The Victor Military Band | 387 | 03/1916 • Stop, Look, and Listen (Medley) • 137 pts
07/1916 • Missouri Waltz • 250 pts |
| 22. | Charles King & Elizabeth Brice | 387 | 07/1916 • That Hula Hula • 137 pts
10/1916 • My Own Iona • 250 pts |
| 23. | Billy Murray & Elsie Baker | 372 | 06/1916 • Some Sort of Somebody • 137 pts
08/1916 • Simple Melody • 235 pts |
| 24. | The Sterling Trio | 354 | 11/1916 • On the South Sea Isle • 177 pts
12/1916 • In Florida Among the Palms • 177 pts |
| 25. | Ada Jones | 344 | 02/1916 • Beatrice Fairfax, Tell Me What to Do! • 195 pts
10/1916 • If I Knock the L Out of Kelly • 149 pts |
| 26. | The Orpheus Quartet | 344 | 11/1916 • Turn Back the Universe and Give Me Yester Day • 344 pts |
| 27. | Emilio DeGogorza | 326 | 01/1916 • Noche Serena (Calm Night) • 177 pts
07/1916 • Non E Ver ('tis Not True) • 149 pts |
| 28. | Gladys Rice & Walter Van Brunt | 311 | 01/1916 • They Didn't Believe Me • 149 pts
08/1916 • Babes in the Wood • 161 pts |
| 29. | Arthur Fields | 296 | 02/1916 • He's Got a Bungalow • 296 pts |
| 30. | Sophie Braslau | 296 | 07/1916 • Birds in the Night (A Lullaby) • 296 pts |
| 31. | Elizabeth Wheeler | 296 | 09/1916 • At the End of a Beautiful Day • 296 pts |
| 32. | Olive Kline & Elsie Baker & Marguerite Dunlap | 250 | 03/1916 • Go to Sleep, My Dusky Baby • 250 pts |
| 33. | Walter Van Brunt | 250 | 12/1916 • I'll Take You Home Again, Kathleen • 250 pts |
| 34. | Sam Ash | 235 | 01/1916 • America, I Love You • 235 pts |
| 35. | Reinald Werrenrath | 235 | 03/1916 • Neapolitan Love Song • 235 pts |
| 36. | Joseph Cawthorn | 235 | 08/1916 • I Can Dance with Everybody but my Wife • 235 pts |
| 37. | John Barnes Wells | 235 | 04/1916 • Memories • 235 pts |
| 38. | Olive Kline | 214 | 05/1916 • Kiss Me Again • 214 pts |
| 39. | Maggie Teyte | 214 | 05/1916 • A Little Love, a Little Kiss • 214 pts |
| 40. | Joe Hayman | 214 | 02/1916 • Cohen Telephones from Brighton • 214 pts |
| 41. | Elsie Baker & Reed Miller | 214 | 07/1916 • Fair Hawaii • 214 pts |
| 42. | The Columbia Mixed Quartet | 213 | 12/1916 • Hark! The Herald Angels Sing • 213 pts |
| 43. | Bert Williams | 213 | 03/1916 • Everybody • 213 pts |
| 44. | The Blue & White Marimba Band | 195 | 04/1916 • Marimba March • 195 pts |
| 45. | Henry Burr & Helen Clark | 195 | 01/1916 • When You're in Love with Someone Who is Not in Love with You • 195 pts |
| 46. | Elsie Baker | 195 | 05/1916 • There's a Broken Heart for Every Light on Broadway • 195 pts |
| 47. | The Victor Light Opera Co. | 195 | 04/1916 • Gems from Very Good, Eddie • 195 pts |
| 48. | The Imperial Quartet of Chicago | 195 | 02/1916 • A Perfect Day • 195 pts |
| 49. | Fritz Kreisler | 195 | 09/1916 • The Old Refrain • 195 pts |
| 50. | Billy Murray & Irving Kaufman | 195 | 04/1916 • Are You from Dixie? ('Cause I'm from Dixie Too) • 195 pts |
| 51. | George Wilton Ballard | 177 | 03/1916 • M-O-T-H-E-R (A Word That Means the World to Me) • 177 pts |
| 52. | Fred Van Eps | 177 | 09/1916 • Hill and Dale • 177 pts |
| 53. | Marion Harris | 161 | 12/1916 • I'm Gonna Make Hay While the Sun Shines in Virginia • 161 pts |
| 54. | Lambert Murphy | 161 | 04/1916 • Underneath the Stars • 161 pts |
| 55. | Ernest Ball | 161 | 07/1916 • Good-Bye, Good Luck, God Bless You • 161 pts |
| 56. | Pietro Deiro | 161 | 07/1916 • Over the Waves Waltz • 161 pts |
| 57. | Louis Gravieure | 161 | 05/1916 • Prologue from Pagliacci • 161 pts |
| 58. | Grace Kerns and Reed Miller | 161 | 07/1916 • They Didn't Believe Me • 161 pts |
| 59. | George MacFarlane | 161 | 02/1916 • My Own Home Town in Ireland • 161 pts |
| 60. | The Lyric Quartet | 149 | 08/1916 • My Dreamy China Lady • 149 pts |
| 61. | The Jaudas' Society Orchestra | 149 | 10/1916 • Missouri Waltz • 149 pts |
| 62. | The Conway's Band | 149 | 09/1916 • Have a Heart - Ziegfeld Follies of 1915 Medley • 149 pts |
| 63. | Russell Hunting | 149 | 03/1916 • Casey's Description of His Fight • 149 pts |
| 64. | M.J. O'Connell | 149 | 09/1916 • It's a Hundred to One You're in Love • 149 pts |
| 65. | Kathleen Parlow | 149 | 10/1916 • Thais: Meditation • 149 pts |
| 66. | Hipolito Lazaro | 149 | 11/1916 • Aida: Celeste Aida (Heavenly Aida) • 149 pts |
| 67. | Harry Lauder | 149 | 07/1916 • My Bonny Bonny Jean • 149 pts |
| 68. | Glen Ellison | 149 | 01/1916 • Face to Face with the Girl in My Dreams • 149 pts |
| 69. | Geraldine Farrar | 149 | 1916 • Mighty Lak' a Rose • 149 pts |
| 70. | Arthur Pryor's Band | 149 | 07/1916 • National Emblem March (New Version) • 149 pts |
| 71. | Reginald McAll | 137 | 11/1916 • Hallelujah Chorus • 137 pts |
| 72. | Reed Miller | 137 | 02/1916 • Love, Here is My Heart • 137 pts |
| 73. | Morton Harvey | 137 | 12/1916 • Turn Back the Universe and Give Me Yesterday • 137 pts |
| 74. | Mischa Elman | 137 | 02/1916 • Spanish Dance • 137 pts |
| 75. | Manuel Romain | 137 | 05/1916 • She's the Daughter of Mother Machree • 137 pts |
| 76. | Lucy Isabelle Marsh | 137 | 08/1916 • Just A-Wearyin' for You • 137 pts |
