| Cover | | Date  | Title • Artist  Album | Points  | Charts Peaks | Comment |
|---|
![All Shook Up [article] All Shook Up [article]](./wp/cache/img/JMGSong_14233.jpg) | 1. | 04/1957 | | 440
 | US ✫1 UK ✫1 US country ✫1 US R&B ✫1 | [Rolling Stone 500 Greatest Songs #352] written by Otis Blackwell, Elvis Presley |
![Jailhouse Rock [article] Jailhouse Rock [article]](./wp/cache/img/JMGSong_14242.jpg) | 2. | 10/1957 | | 411
 | US ✫1 UK ✫1 US country ✫1 US R&B ✫1 | [Rolling Stone 500 Greatest Songs #67] written by Jerry Leiber, Mike Stoller |
| 3. | 07/1957 | | 393
 | US ✫1 UK ✫1 US R&B ✫1 | written by Paul Anka |
| 4. | 01/1957 | | 382
 | US ✫1 UK ✫1 US R&B 8 | written by Ric Cartey, Carole Joyner |
![(Let Me Be Your) Teddy Bear [article] (Let Me Be Your) Teddy Bear [article]](./wp/cache/img/JMGSong_14240.jpg) | 5. | 06/1957 | | 367
 | US ✫1 UK 3 US country ✫1 US R&B ✫1 | written by Kal Mann, Bernie Lowe |
| 6. | 09/1957 | | 352
 | US ✫1 UK 2 US country ✫1 US R&B ✫1 | [Rolling Stone 500 Greatest Songs #311] written by Felice Bryant, Boudleaux Bryant |
![That'll Be the Day [article] That'll Be the Day [article]](./wp/cache/img/JMGSong_7414.jpg) | 7. | 08/1957 | | 351
 | US ✫1 UK ✫1 US R&B 2 | [Rolling Stone 500 Greatest Songs #39] written by Buddy Holly, Jerry Allison, Norman Petty |
| 8. | 05/1957 | | 348
 | US ✫1 UK 2 US R&B 12 | written by J. Fred Coots, Nick Kenny, Charles Kenny |
| 9. | 11/1957 | | 347
 | US 2 UK ✫1 US country ✫1 US R&B 3 | [Rolling Stone 500 Greatest Songs #96] written by Otis Blackwell, Jack Hammer |
| 10. | 02/1957 | | 345
 | US ✫1 UK ✫1 US R&B 14 | written by Bernie Lowe, Kal Mann |
| 11. | 12/1957 | | 335
 | US ✫1 UK 3 US R&B ✫1 | |
![Too Much [article] Too Much [article]](./wp/cache/img/JMGSong_14230.jpg) | 12. | 01/1957 | | 306
 | US ✫1 UK 6 US country 3 US R&B 3 | written by Lee Rosenberg, Bernard Weinman |
| 13. | 03/1957 | | 299
 | US 2 UK 3 US R&B 2 | |
| 14. | 05/1957 | | 292
 | US 2 UK 6 US country ✫1 US R&B 5 | [Rolling Stone 500 Greatest Songs #207] written by Felice Bryant, Boudleaux Bryant |
| 15. | 08/1957 | | 272
 | US ✫1 UK 30 US country 7 US R&B ✫1 | [Roulette 4015] |
| 16. | 01/1957 | | 272
 | US 5 UK 2 US R&B 7 | |
| 17. | 11/1957 | | 264
 | US 2 UK 6 US R&B 2 | [Rolling Stone 500 Greatest Songs #194] |
| 18. | 06/1957 | | 260
 | US 3 UK 8 US country ✫1 US R&B ✫1 | [Rolling Stone 500 Greatest Songs #61] |
| 19. | 11/1957 | | 258
 | US ✫1 UK 12 US R&B 3 | |
| 20. | 11/1957 | | 253
 | US 2 UK 11 US country 6 US R&B ✫1 | written by Bill Justis, Sid Manker |
| 21. | 02/1957 | | 250
 | US ✫1 UK 12 US R&B 10 | written by Bernie Lowe, Kal Mann |
| 22. | 11/1957 | | 249
 | US 3 UK 7 US country 6 US R&B 8 | written by The Weavers [Roulette 4031] |
![You Send Me [article] You Send Me [article]](./wp/cache/img/JMGSong_36406.jpg) | 23. | 10/1957 | | 233
 | US ✫1 UK 29 US R&B ✫1 | [Rolling Stone 500 Greatest Songs #115] written by Sam Cooke |
| 24. | 02/1957 | | 220
 | US ✫1 UK 29 US R&B 3 | written by Buddy Knox, Jimmy Bowen |
| 25. | 11/1957 | | 219
 | US 10 UK 3 US R&B 13 | as Buddy Holly & The Crickets |
| 26. | 12/1957 | | 211
 | US 2 UK 27 US country 8 US R&B 4 | |
| 27. | 05/1957 | | 201
 | US 3 UK 30 US R&B ✫1 | B side to Young Blood |
| 28. | 04/1957 | | 201
 | US 3 UK 24 US R&B ✫1 | |
| 29. | 03/1957 | | 200
 | US 4 UK 19 US R&B ✫1 | |
| 30. | 09/1957 | | 200
 | US ✫1 US R&B 12 | |
| 31. | 02/1957 | | 192
 | US 2 US R&B 4 | #1 hit for Guy Lombardo in 1937 |
| 32. | 06/1957 | | 190
 | US 3 UK 22 US R&B 9 | hit for Fats Waller in 1935 written by Fred E. Ahlert, Joe Young |
| 33. | 06/1957 | | 185
 | US 5 UK 21 US R&B ✫1 | as Larry Williams and His Band |
| 34. | 10/1957 | | 184
 | US 7 UK 22 US country ✫1 US R&B 8 | featuring The Anita Kerr Singers written by Jimmy Duncan |
| 35. | 01/1957 | | 179
 | US 5 UK 23 US R&B ✫1 | |
| 36. | 06/1957 | | 177
 | US 10 UK 11 US R&B 2 | |
| 37. | 02/1957 | | 174
 | US 4 US R&B 2 | [Rolling Stone 500 Greatest Songs #441] written by Clarence Quick |
| 38. | 11/1957 | | 169
 | US 4 US country 11 US R&B ✫1 | written by Bill Justis, Sid Manker |
| 39. | 02/1957 | | 167
 | US 2 US R&B 10 | |
| 40. | 10/1957 | | 163
 | US 3 US R&B 3 | written by Bob Crewe, Frank Slay |